87. Your brain is not broken, it's doing its job

Episode Description:

If you've ever looked at your own negative thinking and wondered "what is wrong with me?" this episode is going to give you the most relieving answer you've ever heard: nothing is wrong with you.

In Episode 87, Janna breaks down exactly why your brain can be so relentlessly critical, why you fixate on the one negative thing your boss said instead of the five positive ones, and why slapping on a positive affirmation and telling yourself it's going to be "an amazing day" almost never works.

The truth? Your brain is functioning exactly as it was designed to. The problem is that it was designed for a world that no longer exists and nobody ever taught you how to work with it instead of against it.

This episode is the first in a series Janna is releasing through October to help you understand your self-critical brain so you can finally start to change it. If you've ever felt exhausted by your own inner critic, like you're the only one this bad at being kind to yourself, or like positivity just doesn't stick this one is for you.

In This Episode You'll Learn:

  • Why your brain is not broken and why that actually matters
  • The evolutionary reason your brain is wired to focus on the negative (it's a survival feature, not a flaw)
  • The three ancient threats your brain is still trying to protect you from in modern life
  • Why the zero-to-seven years of your life had such an outsized impact on how your brain talks to you today
  • Why positive affirmations often don't work (and can actually backfire)
  • What "bridge thoughts" are and why they're so much more effective than jumping straight to positivity
  • How to start working with your brain instead of white-knuckling against it
  • The progression from negative → neutral → genuinely positive (and why skipping steps doesn't work)

Episode Highlights:

[0:00] Janna introduces the episode and October's theme: understanding why we're so self-critical and what we can actually do about it.

[1:11] Your brain has not evolved for modern day society. It's still running hunter-gatherer operating software in a world that looks nothing like the one it was designed for. This is where it all starts.

[4:38] The three reasons your brain treats everyday situations like life-or-death threats: predators (make a mistake = you could get eaten), wrong food choices (bad decision = you could poison yourself or your family), and tribal rejection (get kicked out of the group = your survival odds plummet). Your brain is still treating a critical text message like all three of these.

[9:30]  The zero-to-seven sponge era: how your belief systems, your self-identity, and your brain's entire perception of what's "safe" were built in those early years — and why they've been compounding ever since.

[13:31] The performance review example that perfectly explains negativity bias: your boss gives you five positives and one critique. Which one are you still thinking about three days later? Janna explains exactly why and why it's not your fault.

[15:43] Why therapy alone often doesn't create lasting change: because talking through a situation doesn't reach the factory-level brain programming underneath it. The fix isn't a better plan it's nervous system safety.

[16:15] Why toxic positivity backfires: when you try to leap from "this is going to be the worst day" to "everything is amazing," your brain immediately calls bullshit. It has years of evidence to the contrary, and it will throw the affirmation right out the window.

[18:01] Bridge thoughts: the tool that actually works. Instead of forcing positive, meet your brain in the middle with something it can actually believe. Janna walks through how to use this and what it sounds like in real life.

[19:08] Working with your brain instead of against it: finding one genuinely true thing to focus on (not toxic positivity something real) starts shifting the neural connections in a way that manufactured positivity never will.

[20:12] The path forward: negative → neutral → positive. Why this progression matters, and why skipping to the end doesn't stick.

Key Concepts Covered:

  • Negativity bias: Your brain's built-in tendency to give more weight to threats, mistakes, and criticism than to positives. It's not self-sabotage; it's factory settings designed to keep you alive in a world that no longer exists.
  • Factory settings: Janna's term for the brain's original manufacturer programming: be on high alert, avoid mistakes at all costs, do not get rejected from the tribe. These aren't bad programs  they just don't have a patch for modern life yet.
  • 0-7 belief systems:The years when your brain was absorbing everything around it and forming its core identity, its perception of safety, and its baseline beliefs about who you are and what you deserve. Not just what was said to you what you observed around you.
  • RAS (Reticular Activating System): The brain filter that finds evidence to confirm what you already believe. If your brain believes you're not good enough, it will find evidence for that belief every single day and it's been doing it for decades.
  • Bridge thoughts: Neutral, believable thoughts that bridge the gap between deeply negative and genuinely positive. Your brain can't leap between extremes; it needs a middle ground it can actually accept as true.
  • Toxic positivity: Placing a "good vibes only" statement over a real, unprocessed situation. Your logical brain will reject it immediately because it doesn't match the evidence. Real mindset work isn't about bypassing the negative it's about creating actual safety so the positive can take root.
  • Neuroplasticity: The brain's ability to literally rewire itself and form new connections. The brain you have now is not the brain you're stuck with forever. Every time you catch a thought pattern and shift out of it, you're shrinking the old neural connection and growing a new one.

Reflection Questions From This Episode:

  1. What is your brain currently running on factory settings about? (Work, relationships, money, your worth, where does the inner critic show up loudest?)
  2. What story is your brain finding evidence for every single day?
  3. What's a bridge thought, something neutral and genuinely believable you could use the next time your brain goes to worst-case mode?
  4. Is there one true thing in your current situation that your brain could actually get behind?

Mentioned in This Episode:

This episode is part of Janna's October series: Why We Beat Ourselves Up And How to Finally Stop.

Connect with Janna:

  • Instagram: @jannaholterman
  • Website: www.jannaholterman.com
  • Podcast: Unlocking Your More — available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, and iHeart Radio

Loved this episode?

Share it with someone who has ever said "I don't know why I'm so hard on myself." Because now they'll know and knowing is the first step to actually changing it.

Leave a review so more women find this show and make sure you're subscribed Janna is dropping new episodes every week through October building up to something big.

Keywords: why am I so hard on myself, negativity bias, inner critic, how to stop negative self talk, self-criticism, why affirmations don't work, bridge thoughts, how to rewire your brain, neuroplasticity, toxic positivity, how to be kinder to yourself, stop beating yourself up, negative thinking patterns, brain negativity, evolutionary psychology women, hunter gatherer brain, inner mean girl, mindset coach, nervous system regulation, self-sabotage, high achieving women, Unlocking Your More podcast, Janna Holterman